Provincetown News and Information

Provincetown referred to as "Gay Ghetto" - Gay travlers invited elsewhere

Published: Tue November 07, 2006
By: Straight Dope in Provincetown > Opinion
Tools: Tell-a-Friend | Email this author | This is | Add to Yahoo! MyWeb


(original title: Marketers aim for gay customers)

During what some gays jokingly call “the dark ages” a decade or two ago, companies shunned the gay market out of ignorance or fear of a backlash.

Many cities and convention-and-visitors bureaus overlooked gay travelers. Marketing people lacked hard data to target gay consumers nationwide.

Today, the market for gay and lesbian consumers is highly coveted and hitting the mainstream in a huge way, say consultants, marketing professionals and executives.

The 16 million gay consumers 18 and older in the United States boast $641 billion in buying power, or cash to spend after taxes, reported Witeck-Combs Communications and Harris Interactive.

And corporations and local governments know it.

Last year, 175 Fortune 500 companies—airlines, automakers, financial firms, retailers and others—actively courted the gay dollar through advertising, compared with 19 in 1994, reports the “2005 Gay Press Report” by the Prime Access advertising firm and Rivendell Media Co.

What’s more, dozens of cities that didn’t cater to gay travelers decades ago—including Miami, Dallas, Philadelphia, Phoenix and Bloomington, Ind.—are wooing gays to their hotels, restaurants and nightclubs.

Why now?

“We’re at a tipping point, with gays coming out in society and business,” said Andrew Freeman of Andrew Freeman & Co., a hospitality and restaurant consultancy in San Francisco. “All of a sudden, we’ve become a great market for all industries to go after.”

Recent research, based on U.S. Census data, shows that gays and lesbians live in virtually every county in the United States and aren’t segregated in big cities and “gay ghettos” such as San Francisco, New York, West Hollywood, Calif., or Provincetown, Mass. And millions are smart, technology-savvy consumers and partners with dual household incomes and no kids.

“We have more discretionary income, and we love to spend our money on travel and shopping,” said Thomas Roth, president of Community Marketing, a gay market research firm that recently hosted a gay tourism conference in San Francisco. “That’s really opening the eyes of Corporate America.”

The gay market is drawing attention from:

# Companies. Travel industry-related firms from United Airlines to Travelocity have stepped up their marketing to gays. ABC Carpet & Home in New York has a gay wedding registry for same-sex partners. Wal-Mart offers seminars to employees, called “Why Market to Gay America.”

At American Airlines, managers George Carrancho and Betty Young head a team that markets to gay travelers and small businesses. The airline sponsors community events and offers a gay-oriented Web site,, with travel deals, an e-newsletter, podcasts and a gay events calendar.

American has focused on gay consumers since 1994, when a gay manager persuaded former CEO Robert Crandall that gay travelers were an untapped market. Crandall agreed. Since then, the company has enjoyed annual, double-digit revenue growth for gay customers.

“We’re committed to this market,” Carrancho said.

# Cities and tourism bureaus. In years past, local governments and tourism offices—aside from San Francisco and a handful of other cities—“politely ignored” gay travelers and businesses, Roth said

Now, dozens of cities and convention bureaus are going all out to lure gay visitors. They’re spending millions of dollars on print, TV and online advertising. They’re showcasing cultural and film festivals, gay parades and gay--friendly hotels and restaurants.

In Miami, tourism officials—downplaying Florida’s old image as a retirement site—use splashy travel literature and commercials to showcase the region’s nightlife, museums, the performing arts and ethnic neighborhoods. They work closely with the Miami-Dade Gay & Lesbian Chamber of Commerce, whose travel guide reads: “Miami: Diversity Celebrated Daily . . . Come feel the vibe.”

“Gays are good for business and good for our community,” said George Neary, director of cultural tourism for the Greater Miami Convention & Visitors Bureau. “The partnership works.”

# Mainstream marketing. Many more businesses engage in crossover marketing, advertising not only in gay media outlets, but also mainstream ones.

Frances Stevens, founder and publisher of lesbian magazine Curve, joked that the new ads are much classier than the old ones, which featured brawny, hairy men toting beers.

Advertisers are much more sophisticated about the buying habits of gays and lesbians. They know, for instance, that many lesbian couples live in the suburbs, raise children and are very loyal to particular brands, whether cars, cell phones or clothing.

“The old image of lesbians wearing flannel and eating granola bars is not an accurate picture of the market,” said Stevens, whose current issue of Curve features advertisers Showtime, Pepsi and Washington Mutual.

At Kimpton Hotels & Restaurants, a San Francisco-based chain of boutique hotels, consumer research has found that straight and lesbian businesswomen and vacationers share similar values, lifestyles and hobbies, said Chief Operating Officer Niki Leondakis. They like spas and fitness offerings, classy interior decor and personal service from friendly staffers. They prefer to spend on companies that support women and give to nonprofits. Also important: personal safety and good security at hotels.

Kimpton offers getaway packages and many other popular promotions to lesbians and straight women—a large and growing segment of their regular guests.

“The market has enormous potential that just now is coming to light,” Leondakis said.

Companies that cater to gays and lesbians still risk a backlash from fundamentalist religious groups, which have called for boycotts of companies that market to gays, donate to gay nonprofits or portray gays as “normal” families in ads.

In recent years, Ford Motor, Walt Disney, Kraft Foods, Procter & Gamble and other companies have felt the ire of the American Family Association and other fundamentalist groups.

Despite the potential for controversy, a recent survey by Opinion Research and Fleishman-Hilliard found that 68 percent of Americans would still buy from companies that marketed to gays.

Demographers have found that, contrary to old stereotypes, gays cut across all lifestyles, ethnic groups and generations, said Bob Witeck, head of Witeck Combs and author of “Business Inside Out: Capturing Millions of Brand-Loyal Gay Consumers.”

Many are “early adopters,” or consumers who love new technologies, from the latest laptop computers to the flashiest personal digital assistants.

Gary Humbarger, 44, a gay copywriter, travel adviser and avid online shopper, loves the special touch from companies.

On a recent trip with his partner to Santa Fe, N.M., he rented a car from Budget and was pleased to learn that he didn’t have to pay the typical charge for an extra driver. Why not? Because Budget treats gay partners like married spouses.

“If a company has a good record with gays, I’m certainly going to remember that,” Humbarger said. “I speak with my dollars.”

Find Provincetown items on eBay

Find Provincetown items on Amazon


On Tue November 07, 2006, Straight Dope wrote:

"Recent research, based on U.S. Census data, shows that gays and lesbians live in virtually every county in the United States and aren’t segregated in big cities and “gay ghettos” such as San Francisco, New York, West Hollywood, Calif., or Provincetown, Mass.”

Interesting term. Not very flattering.

Anyway, has the gay dollar left Provincetown? If so, who is the next target audience and how will the Provincetown Chamber, the Provincetown Business Guild, the Visitor Services Board et al attract the next generation of tourist dollars?

With more second home owners than ever, the town has less tourist turnover, less units for rent and less places for workers to stay.

Also, 2007 will see a new Town Manager, new chairman of the Board of Selectmen, new head of Coastal Studies and new head of the Pilgrim Monument.

Looks like a few “rebuilding” years are in order.

On Tue November 07, 2006, Straight Dope wrote:

Will the new Septembers and Octobers lift the old Julys and Augusts? Maybe Novembers and Decembers too but January 2 through May 31, forget about it.

On Tue November 07, 2006, czarina wrote:

With everyone jumping on the gay tourist bandwagon, Provincetown is no longer one of the major destinations for G&L travellers. The Town could target second home owners .

Submit A Comment

View all Provincetown Journal provincetown articles in 2006


Write Here

Articles Archive



Explore a variety of Provincetown related products in our Marketplace

  • Provincetown logo merchandise
  • Provincetown Journal merchandise
  • Cape Cod domain names
BlogWise ExpressionEngine

Also read our sister publication the Havana Journal